请问,关于英国法律的mischief rule和purposive approach
答案:1 悬赏:70 手机版
解决时间 2021-11-29 16:22
- 提问者网友:蓝琪梦莎
- 2021-11-29 00:01
请问,关于英国法律的mischief rule和purposive approach
最佳答案
- 五星知识达人网友:低血压的长颈鹿
- 2021-11-29 00:27
c) Mischief Rule
The mischief rule is an old version of the purposive approach. It means that to remedy the mischief, the court is required to interprete the words by looking at the difference in previous law.
The signaficance of mischief rule is that it makes the act work as parliament intented, but it can be argued that this destories the parliament supremacy. Anyway, this correct the mischief and avoid the absurd or unjust results, which are better than literal rule and golden rule.
d) Purposive Approach
The purposive approach looks for the intention of the parliament and of ministers. It is not only regard at the difference in previous law, but also allow for the judicial law making. In another word, both golden rule and the mischief rule are the applications of the purposive approach.
The only issue to this approach is how to determine the intentions of parliament and whether judges should refuse to follow the words of parliament. On the good side, this approach looks for the intention of the parliament and allows the judicial law making. However, people criticised about the usurpation of the legislative function.
这是我的assignment。。。理解就是这样的
The mischief rule is an old version of the purposive approach. It means that to remedy the mischief, the court is required to interprete the words by looking at the difference in previous law.
The signaficance of mischief rule is that it makes the act work as parliament intented, but it can be argued that this destories the parliament supremacy. Anyway, this correct the mischief and avoid the absurd or unjust results, which are better than literal rule and golden rule.
d) Purposive Approach
The purposive approach looks for the intention of the parliament and of ministers. It is not only regard at the difference in previous law, but also allow for the judicial law making. In another word, both golden rule and the mischief rule are the applications of the purposive approach.
The only issue to this approach is how to determine the intentions of parliament and whether judges should refuse to follow the words of parliament. On the good side, this approach looks for the intention of the parliament and allows the judicial law making. However, people criticised about the usurpation of the legislative function.
这是我的assignment。。。理解就是这样的
我要举报
如以上问答信息为低俗、色情、不良、暴力、侵权、涉及违法等信息,可以点下面链接进行举报!
大家都在看
推荐资讯