永发信息网

托尔金的故事锅理论出自1947年,在名为《论神话》(On Fairy Stories)的文章中,有英文的理论吗?或者你知道神话论的具体的出版地点吗?

答案:1  悬赏:30  手机版
解决时间 2021-06-06 11:44
托尔金的故事锅理论出自1947年,在名为《论神话》(On Fairy Stories)的文章中,有英文的理论吗?或者你知道神话论的具体的出版地点吗?
最佳答案

亲爱的,你到底想问什么?Speaking of the history of stories and especially of fairy-stories we may say that the Pot of Soup, the Cauldron of Story, has always been boiling, and to it have continually been added new bits, dainty and undainty. For this reason, to take a casual example, the fact that a story resembling the one known as The Goosegirl (Die Gänsemagd in Grimm) is told in the thirteenth century of Bertha Broadfoot, mother of Charlemagne, really proves nothing either way: neither that the story was (in the thirteenth century) descending from Olympus or Asgard by way of an already legendary king of old, on its way to become a Hausmärchen; nor that it was on its way up. The story is found to be widespread, unattached to the mother of Charlemagne or to any historical character. From this fact by itself we certainly cannot deduce that it is not true of Charlemagne's mother, though that is the kind of deduction that is most frequently made from that kind of evidence. The opinion that the story is not true of Bertha Broadfoot must be founded on something else: on features in the story which the critic's philosophy does not allow to be possible in “real life,” so that he would actually disbelieve the tale, even if it were found nowhere else; or on the existence of good historical evidence that Bertha's actual life was quite different, so that he would disbelieve the tale, even if his philosophy allowed that it was perfectly possible in “real life.” No one, I fancy, would discredit a story that the Archbishop of Canterbury slipped on a banana skin merely because he found that a similar comic mishap had been reported of many people, and especially of elderly gentlemen of dignity. He might disbelieve the story, if he discovered that in it an angel (or even a fairy) had warned the Archbishop that he would slip if he wore gaiters on a Friday. He might also disbelieve the story, if it was stated to have occurred in the period between, say, 1940 and 1945. So much for that. It is an obvious point, and it has been made before; but I venture to make it again (although it is a little beside my present purpose), for it is constantly neglected by those who concern themselves with the origins of tales.

我要举报
如以上问答信息为低俗、色情、不良、暴力、侵权、涉及违法等信息,可以点下面链接进行举报!
大家都在看
游戏人生 怎么整呀???
营门口立交附近有个人才市场叫什么人才市场啊
卧龙区南阳电力医院-急诊地址在什么地方,想
qq炫舞围绕人物的东东
脸色发黄是因为什么?
- - . 我需要那个< 心酸的承诺>的歌词
为什么门派换石头的道人 我给了10J没有给我石
请问1981年10月19日午时出生的生辰八字,农历
2009年有什么好看的电影没?
为什么找不到中国历史的书呢
QQ宠物的1级藏宝图宝藏
抽中紫钻需要领吗?
禹州市许昌金利福珠宝(钧州大街)这个地址在什
揭阳哪里有卖情趣内衣。(大概几钱)
高速路广告审批的流程有哪些呢?
推荐资讯
张深的艺术简明怎么弄?
谁有南昌东方电脑城OPPO专卖柜的联系电话或者
在北京,从白石桥东怎么坐公交到方庄桥南
天真的个性不好吗?
三亚哪里有水货手机卖
很好的朋友也会嫉妒对方吗?如果有这种感觉还
按这个行情需要多少G能到70
我想要一个游戏人生资格 好人请传给我 一定5
解放区焦作中国电信(鸿运通讯专营店)地址是什
荣光医院的空间站和几何空间,每花10元宝只能
还有什么好玩的游戏啊
怎么把开目CAD得图转化到AOUTCAD
正方形一边上任一点到这个正方形两条对角线的
阴历怎么看 ?